Manufacturing & custom software · Bengaluru · Whitefish, USA
Manufacturing

In-Process Quality Inside the MES: Checks at the Operation, Not After It

How connecting quality management with the MES puts the right inspection at the right operation: checks triggered by the job, readings against limits, holds that stop bad parts moving, NCRs from the floor and traceable quality records.

By Corposol Team··9 min read
Outside micrometer in its storage case
Photo: Micrometer SOGIMO by Mystrixo, CC BY-SA 4.0 (cropped)

In many factories, quality and production run in parallel but separately. Production makes parts; quality inspects them — at the end of the line, in a separate room, or on a patrol round every couple of hours. Inspection reports are filled on paper and filed. When a problem is found, a batch of parts made since the last good check is already suspect, and the record of what happened is spread across job cards, inspection sheets and someone's memory.

Putting quality checks inside the MES — at the operation where the characteristic is created — changes this. The right check appears at the right time, readings are recorded against limits as they are taken, failures stop parts moving, and every record is linked to the job, machine, operator and material. This guide explains how quality management and the MES work together on the shop floor.

Why separate systems fall short

  • Checks are missed. The operator is supposed to check every 50 parts; on a busy shift, nobody notices when a check is skipped.
  • Readings are written later. Values are copied from scrap paper at the end of the shift, or invented to fill the sheet.
  • Failures don't stop the flow. A part out of tolerance is noted, but the rest of the batch moves on.
  • Records can't be linked. Which job, which machine, which material lot did this reading come from? On paper, often unclear.
  • Analysis is impossible. Paper readings can't be trended without being typed in, so they aren't.

Checks defined in the routing

The foundation is to define inspection checks as part of each operation in the routing, typically from the control plan:

  • Characteristic — the dimension, feature or property to check.
  • Specification — nominal and limits, or attribute criteria.
  • Method and gauge — how to check and with what.
  • Frequency — first-off, every N parts, every N minutes, last-off.
  • Sample size.
  • Responsible role — operator, inspector or setter.
  • Reaction plan — what to do if the check fails.

Our guide to control plans explains how these are developed.

Checks triggered by the job

When an operator starts a job on the MES, the checks for that operation are loaded automatically. The tablet shows when each check is due — first-off now, then every 50 parts based on booked quantity, or every hour — and reminds the operator when one is overdue. Checks become part of the job flow rather than a separate task to remember.

Readings against limits

The operator or inspector enters each reading on a number pad, or — where instruments support it — the reading is captured directly. The screen compares it immediately with the limits:

  • Within limits — green, continue.
  • Near a limit — amber, a warning to adjust before parts go out of tolerance.
  • Out of limits — red, the reaction plan starts.

Recording the gauge used, by scanning its tag, links each reading to the gauge's calibration status at the time — something auditors frequently check. See our guide to keeping quality records ready for audits.

Holds that stop bad parts moving

The most important capability is the hold. When a check fails, the job or the current lot is placed on hold in the MES. While on hold:

  • Output can't be booked as good.
  • The job can't be completed or moved to the next operation.
  • Parts made since the last good check are identified as suspect.

Quality is notified, reviews the situation, and releases, sorts, reworks or scraps the suspect parts. The decision is recorded. This prevents the most expensive kind of quality failure: a known problem that nobody stopped.

NCRs from the shop floor

A failed check that leads to rejection or rework creates a non-conformance record automatically, already linked to the part, operation, job, machine, operator, material lot and the failing reading. Quality adds disposition and, where needed, root cause and corrective action. Compared with an NCR raised days later from a paper report, this one is complete, accurate and immediate. See NCR management software.

First-off and setup approval

After every setup, the first parts are checked before production continues. In the MES, the job can't move into production booking until the first-off check is recorded and approved by the authorised person. This simple rule prevents a large share of batch rejections caused by setup errors, and records exactly who approved each setup and on what evidence. Our first article inspection guide covers the broader topic.

Readings recorded digitally against each job can be charted immediately. For key characteristics, simple control charts on the tablet show whether the process is drifting before it goes out of tolerance, so the operator can adjust in time. Over longer periods, capability by machine and part shows where processes need improvement. Our guide to SPC basics for small factories explains the method.

Rejections booked with production

When operators book production, they also book rejections with a defect reason. Combined with in-process check results, this gives a complete picture: where defects are created, which operations and machines have the highest rejection rates, and how rejection rates change over time. Rejection data by operation is far more useful than a final-inspection rejection rate that says nothing about where the problem started.

Traceable records without extra work

Because checks are done within the MES job, every quality record carries the job, operation, machine, operator, material lot, gauge and time automatically. When a customer complaint arrives, the history of the affected lot — every check, every reading, every hold — is available immediately. See our guide to handling OEM customer rejections.

Changing a check

Checks change when drawings are revised, control plans are updated after a complaint, or capability improves enough to reduce frequency. In the MES, a change to a check is made once, approved by quality, given an effective date and applied to jobs from that point. The history shows which version of the check applied to each job — something paper systems struggle with, because old sheets stay in circulation. Linking check changes to the reason (customer complaint, PFMEA review, engineering change) gives auditors the trail they look for.

Quality data for the daily meeting

Because in-process results are recorded live, the morning production meeting can start with yesterday's quality: checks overdue or missed, holds raised and released, rejections by operation and the top defect. Problems are discussed while they are fresh, and actions are assigned before the same defect repeats on the next shift. This daily rhythm, built on reliable data, often does more for quality than any single technical improvement.

Shared screens, separate roles

Operators, inspectors and supervisors may all use the same shop-floor tablet. Each logs in with their badge, sees only the checks assigned to their role and signs off with their own identity. This keeps responsibility clear and records reliable without needing a separate device for every person on the floor.

Rolling it out

  1. Start with first-off approval on one section — high value, easy to adopt.
  2. Add in-process checks for the critical characteristics from the control plan.
  3. Turn on holds for failed checks once operators are used to recording.
  4. Link NCRs and quality's disposition workflow.
  5. Add trends and SPC for key characteristics.
  6. Review final inspection and reduce it where in-process checks give reliable control.

Operator checks versus inspector checks

A balanced quality system uses both operators and inspectors. Operators are at the machine all the time; they are best placed to check frequent, simple characteristics with fixed gauges — go/no-go, simple dimensions, visual checks — and to react immediately. Inspectors bring independence and more complex measurement: first-off approvals, patrol inspection at lower frequency, characteristics needing a height gauge, CMM or special equipment. The MES assigns each check to the right role, presents it at the right time and records who did it. A patrol inspector's tablet can show which machines have checks due and which have failed recently, so patrol rounds go where they are needed rather than following a fixed route.

Visual defects and photos

Not every check is a measurement. Surface defects, burrs, dents, colour and finish are judged visually against standards. On a tablet, the check can show reference photos of acceptable and unacceptable conditions next to the defect list, which makes judgements more consistent between operators and shifts. When a defect is found, a photo attached to the rejection gives quality and engineering the evidence they need, and builds a library of real defects for training.

Reaction plans that are followed

Control plans specify what to do when a check fails, but paper reaction plans are often forgotten under pressure. In the MES, the reaction plan becomes a sequence on the screen: stop, hold the parts since the last good check, inform the supervisor and quality, adjust or call maintenance, re-check before restarting. Each step is confirmed and timestamped. When a customer asks what you did when a problem occurred, the record shows exactly what happened, who did it and when — far more convincing than a procedure that says what should have happened.

Making checks fast

Operators will do checks reliably only if recording them is fast. Use number pads for readings, pre-filled gauges where the operation always uses the same one, and pass/fail buttons for attribute checks. A check that takes longer to record than to measure will be batched or skipped. Test the screens with operators and remove every unnecessary field.

Material and incoming quality

In-process quality depends on the material going in. When material lots are scanned at issue, in-process results can be compared by material lot and supplier. A rise in rejections that coincides with a new lot of bar or coil points to the material rather than the process, and the supplier can be shown the evidence. Linking incoming inspection results for that lot completes the picture. This connection between incoming and in-process quality is one of the most useful — and most often missing — in SME quality systems.

A worked example

An auto component supplier machining hubs and brackets had a final inspection team checking samples from each lot, and operators were supposed to check critical bores every 25 parts, recording readings on paper. Customer complaints occasionally revealed lots with out-of-tolerance bores that had passed final sampling.

The supplier moved first-off approvals and bore checks into the MES on shop-floor tablets, with gauges scanned and holds on failed readings. In the first weeks, the system showed that checks on the night shift were frequently overdue — something the paper sheets had hidden. Overdue reminders and supervisor alerts brought compliance up. Trend charts for the critical bore showed tool wear drifting the size towards the limit before tool changes; tool change intervals were adjusted. Bore-related customer complaints stopped, and final inspection sampling was reduced for parts with stable in-process records.

Working with Corposol

Corposol builds custom quality management and MES software in which in-process checks, holds and NCRs are part of the shop-floor job flow, as part of our manufacturing software work for Indian SMEs. All custom code is transferred to you on final payment.

Frequently asked questions

What is in-process inspection in an MES?

Inspection checks defined for each operation in the routing, presented to the operator or inspector at the right time during the job, with readings recorded against specification limits on the shop-floor tablet.

Can the MES stop parts moving if a check fails?

Yes. A failed check can put the job or lot on hold, so it can't be booked as complete or moved to the next operation until quality decides what to do.

Who should do in-process checks — operators or inspectors?

Both, usually. Operators do frequent, simple checks at their machine; inspectors do less frequent, more detailed checks and first-off approvals. The MES assigns each check to the right role.

Does this replace final inspection?

Not entirely, but it usually reduces it. When in-process checks are done and recorded reliably, final inspection can focus on characteristics that can't be checked earlier, and on sampling.

  • In-process inspection
  • MES
  • Quality management
  • Shop-floor quality
  • NCR

Let's discuss your factory's software

Tell us about your process or idea. You'll get a free consultation and a clear, fixed quote — no obligation.

  • Free consultation
  • Prototype before you commit
  • Fixed, itemised quote
  • You own the software

Get a free quote

We reply within one working day. Your details are never shared.